Blair
Speak: Does Tony Blair speak differently from everyone else?
Here are the ten most frequent words Tony Blair used in interviews with the media at the start of the Iraq war compared with the top ten in the British National Corpus (BNC) sample.
|
Adjectives |
Nouns |
|
|||
|
Blair |
BNC |
Blair |
BNC |
Blair |
BNC |
1 |
economic |
new |
people |
time
|
say |
say |
2 |
fair |
good |
inspectors |
people |
think |
know |
3 |
nuclear |
old |
countries |
way |
make |
get |
4 |
true |
different |
Iraq |
year |
know |
go |
5 |
difficult |
local |
weapons |
government |
try |
see |
6 |
wrong |
small |
resolution |
day |
come |
make |
7 |
Iraqi |
great |
issue |
man |
mean |
think |
8 |
united |
social |
time |
world |
happen |
take |
9 |
clear |
important |
world |
work |
go |
come |
10 |
important |
national |
UN |
life |
take |
use |
The main differences between them are that Blair uses:
· more adjectives like economic, less adjectives like new
· more nouns like country, less like way
· more verbs like think and mean (often called personal verbs, as they express personal views), less like use
The pronouns I/she/they/etc are often a clue to how a person’s mind works. In the BNC compared to BlairSpeak, Tony Blair is using proportionately more first person (I/we) forms and less third person (he/she/it/they) forms than the BNC average. It was said that Charles de Gaulle did not use the first person je very often in speeches because whenever he talked about La France, he actually meant himself, in the tradition of Louis XIV’s L’état c’est moi (The state is me). Tony Blair’s speech sounds more egocentric than the BNC average. To be charitable, this might tell us something about the differences between the type of English used in interviews and the average English of the BNC. Or it might indeed be that Tony Blair is basically interested in talking about himself.
Did
Blair ever say sorry?
The only five examples of Tony Blair apologising in the interviews were:
·
I'm
sorry, that is simply not right.
·
I’m
sorry, Jeremy, I'm not allowing you to get away with that, that is completely
wrong.
·
I
mean let's not be absurdly naïve about this – I'm sorry, what Hans Blix has
said is that the Iraqis are not cooperating properly.
·
I'm
sorry, it is absolutely clear what has been happening over the past few months
·
If
that is breached and the inspectors say, no I'm sorry we can't do our job and in
those circumstances …
All
these are apologising for contradicting somebody by asserting one’s own
opinion, i.e. not an apology at all – equivalent to the deadly use of with
respect for contradiction.